1. Introduction
Cane sugar manufacture leaves molasses, the syrup that remains once further sucrose can no longer be crystallized economically. Its composition varies widely between mills and cane sources: across 16 cane molasses samples sourced worldwide, sucrose spanned 39.2 %–67.3 % of dry matter and the inorganic residue averaged 13.1 % of dry matter [1]. Molasses is used as an animal feed and as a fermentation substrate for ethanol, yeast, and amino acids. World output is estimated at 55 million tonnes per year [2]. The fermentation route returns a spent wash whose organic load, low pH, and dark color place it among the more difficult industrial effluents to treat, and inadequately treated discharge from cane sugar and distillery operations is a documented source of soil and water pollution in producing regions [3]. Converting molasses directly into a solid carbon material is an outlet that does not pass through that effluent.
Hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) converts an aqueous biomass feed into a carbon-rich solid under autogenous pressure at temperatures commonly below those used for pyrolysis [4]. The route suits a wet feed such as molasses because no drying is required before conversion. Sugars dehydrate, condense, and polymerize in the liquid phase and form predominantly amorphous carbon micro- or nanospheres [5, 6]. Yield and surface chemistry depend on the feedstock, the solid-to-water ratio, temperature, and residence time, so each has to be separated from any performance the product is later credited with [7, 8, 9]. Recent work on molasses and sugar-industry residues has varied mainly the reaction temperature, additives, and activation. Date-palm molasses carbonized at 180 to 250 °C gave carbon microspheres in up to 40.4 % yield but with Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) areas below 1 m2 g−1 [10], and porous products were obtained only after phosphoric acid activation [11] or with ferrate and iron additives [12]. Cane molasses has also served as the carbon source for a magnetic amino-functional material [13], while press mud and bagasse hydrochars have been assessed as fuels and soil amendments [14] or activated for pesticide removal [15, 16]. How the charge of feed into a fixed water volume governs recovery, which sets the material balance of a valorization route, has received less attention.
Ammonium reaches surface water through municipal and industrial effluents, landfill leachate, and agricultural runoff. At elevated loads it contributes to eutrophication and the associated loss of water quality and ecosystem function [17, 18]. Adsorption is attractive as a polishing step because it is simple to operate and can treat dilute streams, and hydrochars from agricultural and industrial residues have been tested against metals and nutrient ions on that basis [19, 20]. Unmodified hydrochars from sugarcane bagasse and leaves have taken up about 3 to 20 mg g−1 ammonium [21, 22], and a paper-sludge hydrochar about 20 mg g−1 [23]. Ammonium uptake by chars does not follow surface area alone: surface functional groups, ash composition, pH, and cation-exchange properties can be equally important [20, 24, 25], and competing and halved the uptake of a sugarcane hydrochar in digestate [22]. A loading series can thus change mass recovery, bulk structure, and surface affinity by different amounts, and the three have to be established separately.
Two questions follow, and they are of different kinds. The first is
chemical: whether changing how much molasses is charged into a fixed
water volume changes the solid that forms, or only how much of it is
recovered. The second is evidential. Adsorption performance is often
reported in a form that cannot be checked against the measurement
behind it. A critical review of the field documents recurring problems
with the quantities used to express performance, with kinetic and
isotherm fitting, and with data points that are inconsistent between
experiment and model [26], and the apparent
dominance of the pseudo-second-order rate law has been traced to
modeling conventions that favor it rather than to the kinetics of the
systems it is fitted to [27]. Recent hydrochar
studies still select isotherms by
We compared 10, 15, and 20 g molasses in a fixed 50 mL water volume, characterized the solids, and measured ammonium uptake as a function of contact time and initial concentration, working throughout from the complete batch record and the raw spectroscopic and adsorption measurements rather than from summary values. The characterization answers the first question and separates the part of the product that loading changes from the part it does not. The second question is answered in the negative: we report the analytical boundary that produces that answer, and the measurements needed to cross it, rather than nominal capacities computed beyond it.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1 Materials
Molasses was collected from the Cinta Manis sugar factory in Ogan
Ilir, South Sumatra, Indonesia, and used as received without
filtration or dilution. Ammonium chloride (analytical grade,
2.2 Hydrochar Preparation
Molasses feed of 10, 15, or 20 g was mixed with 50 mL deionized water in a 100 mL beaker. The mixture was transferred to a PTFE-lined reactor and held at 140 °C for 24 h. The resulting suspension was recovered under vacuum, washed with ethanol and water, and dried at 80 °C for 12 h. Hydrochar yield was calculated on the as-received molasses mass basis,
A second series was prepared at 140 °C for 10 h and is compared with the 24 h products in Section 3.3. Only its temperature and residence time were recorded; whether it passed through the same mixing, washing, and drying steps was not.
A portion of the product from each feed loading was then heated in a covered crucible in air at 10 °C min−1 to 400 °C and held for 2 h; this treated fraction, denoted MH10-400, MH15-400, and MH20-400, was the adsorbent used in the ammonium experiments. Its mass after treatment was not measured, and the treated material was not characterized: the characterization data in Section 3 describe the products before this step. Heating hydrochar in air at 300 to 450 °C is a common activation step that adds oxygen-containing surface groups [30] and, toward the upper end of that range, burns off carbon and enriches the ash [31]. The route, and the measurement each product received, are summarized in Fig. 1.
2.3 Material Characterization
Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectra were recorded on a
Shimadzu IRSpirit spectrometer through a single-reflection diamond
attenuated-total-reflection accessory, over 401.6 cm–3998.8 cm at
628 points, giving a sampling interval of 5.737 cm, at 4 cm
resolution with 45 accumulations and Happ–Genzel apodization. Six
spectra were measured consecutively in one session: three from the
10 h products and three from the 24 h products. On export the
instrument software adds a constant per-sample transmittance offset,
between
X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns were collected on a PANalytical
diffractometer in a spinner reflection–transmission configuration
with Cu K
Crystalline reflections were separated from the amorphous
scattering before phase identification. The broad background was
estimated by iterative SNIP clipping [34] and
subtracted, and maxima in the residual were retained when they
exceeded four times the local noise, cleared a prominence threshold,
and had a full width at half maximum below 1.5 ° measured above the
local background. Retained reflections were matched against the
experimental cards of the PDF-2 powder diffraction
file [35]; a phase was accepted only when
its strongest line and its strong companions were all present as
detected reflections with intensity ratios consistent with the
card [36]. Whewellite and calcite were carried as
negative controls. The identification is qualitative, and no weight
fractions are reported. The amorphous band was characterized
separately by fitting a Gaussian on a linear background over
12 °–32 °
Surface morphology and elemental composition were examined on a
Thermo Fisher Quattro scanning electron microscope with an
Everhart–Thornley detector in secondary-electron mode at 10.00 kV,
spot size 2.5, and working distances of 10.6 mm–12.6 mm, coupled to
a Bruker energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometer operated in mapping
mode. Micrographs were taken at five carbonization temperatures,
140, 175, 180, 200, and 220 °C, each at
1000
Sample identities follow the labels the measurements themselves carry. Spectra h1024, h1524, and h2024 are taken as the 24 h products from the 10, 15, and 20 g feeds, and H10, H15, and h20 as the corresponding 10 h products; the acquisition order places the 10 h set immediately before the 24 h set within the single session. Diffraction patterns HD, HE, and HF are assigned to the same loading sequence. These assignments are provisional, since no independent sample list accompanies the measurements. Three further patterns, HA, HB, and HC, are not assigned to any feed loading.
2.4 Ammonium Adsorption Experiments
An ammonium stock was prepared by dissolving 1 g ammonium chloride in 1 L deionized water. Working standards labeled 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 mg L−1 were reacted with 0.2 mL Nessler reagent and measured at 450 nm. Absorbances were read on a Shimadzu UV-1280 spectrophotometer. The color-development time before reading, the final made-up volume, and the reagent blank were not recorded, and this is the only calibration: no second curve reaches the absorbances at which the samples were read. Concentrations are expressed as throughout.
Contact-time experiments used 0.1 g of MH10-400, MH15-400, or MH20-400 in 500 mL of a nominal 20 mg L−1 ammonium solution at 250 rpm. Contact times were 5, 10, 15, 30, 45, 60, 75, 90, 120, 150, and 180 min. Initial-concentration experiments used 0.1 g adsorbent in 100 mL solution at nominal concentrations of 5, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, and 80 mg L−1 for 60 min at 250 rpm. Each condition was measured twice. A 10 mL aliquot was passed through a PTFE syringe filter, reacted with 0.2 mL Nessler reagent, and analyzed by UV-Vis spectroscopy. Solutions were neither pH-adjusted nor thermostatted, and pH and temperature were not measured; whether each time point came from an independent vessel or was drawn sequentially from one was not recorded. Sequential sampling would reduce the solution volume across the series, which Eq. (2) treats as constant.
Nominal adsorption capacity was calculated as
where
2.5 Data Analysis
Every recorded 24 h synthesis batch was included in the yield analysis. Loading was related to wet-feed yield using Spearman’s rank correlation [38] and compared among groups using the Kruskal–Wallis test [39]. Group sizes and production dates were unequal and were not adjusted for.
The five calibration standards were refitted by ordinary least
squares. Contact-time observations were fitted directly, without
linearization, to pseudo-first-order and pseudo-second-order
models [40] and to a constant response after the first
5 min measurement, and the fits were compared by the small-sample
corrected Akaike information criterion
(AICc) [41, 42].
Langmuir [43], Freundlich [44], and
linear partition models were fitted to the concentration series to
test whether the observed concentration range bounds a saturation
capacity; a Langmuir
| Molasses feed (g per 50 mL) | Yield (%) | Range (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 5 | 11.74 |
10.33–12.68 |
| 15 | 4 | 17.49 |
16.49–19.24 |
| 20 | 3 | 18.38 |
17.09–20.72 |
3. Results and Discussion
3.1 Feed Loading and Hydrochar Recovery
The complete 24 h record contains five batches at 10 g, four at
15 g, and three at 20 g
(Fig. 2 and
Table 1). Mean wet-feed
yield increased by 5.75 between 10 and 15 g, but by only 0.89
between 15 and 20 g. Feed loading was strongly associated with yield
(
The maximum yield at each loading is 12.68, 19.24, and 20.72 %; reporting those three values alone would preserve the apparent direction of the response but suppress its spread. The full record supports an association between loading and recovered mass, not a clean causal loading effect: synthesis dates and group sizes are unbalanced, and the production sequence was neither randomized nor blocked. The small change from 15 to 20 g may indicate diminishing recovery at the highest solid-to-water ratio, but a balanced batch series is needed to test that interpretation.
Feed load is one of the variables through which hydrothermal carbonization distributes mass between the solid, liquid, and gas products [45], and for saccharides the concentration of the starting solution changes the particles themselves as well as how much of them is recovered [46]. These recoveries are not directly comparable with published yields, for two reasons that both work in the same direction: they are referred to the as-received molasses rather than to its dry matter, and 140 °C lies below the 170 °C–240 °C range over which saccharide hydrochars are usually prepared [46].
3.2 Bulk Structural Similarity Across the Loading Series
All six spectra carry the same band set (Fig. 3a,b). Second derivatives resolve bands near 1700, 1610, 1510, 1455, 1315, 1210, and 1025 cm, together with weaker features near 790 and 520 cm and an aliphatic band near 2920 cm. Positions are reported to the nearest 5 cm because the sampling interval is 5.737 cm. Not every band clears the detection threshold in every spectrum, but the blanks track derivative noise, which differs fourfold across the six measurements, rather than composition. The 1700 cm band is the most informative of the set for a sugar-derived char, and it is present in all six.
Above these, a broad envelope spans roughly 3000 cm–3600 cm. Its apparent maximum moves between 3310 and 3385 cm across the six spectra as the smoothing window is varied, a range wider than any difference between samples, so a single position for it would describe the filter rather than the material, and none is quoted. Taken together the positions are consistent with a hydroxyl-rich, oxygen-containing carbon surface carrying carbonyl and functionality, but the spectra do not resolve individual ester, ketone, ether, and carboxyl contributions without calibrated band fitting or supporting surface analysis.
Pairwise correlation of the absorbance spectra does not
discriminate between these samples. Within the 24 h series it
reaches
XRD patterns are similarly close (
The apparent position of the amorphous maximum is not, however, a
safe summary statistic here. Smoothing the raw patterns places the
maximum near 21.39, 20.99, and 24.95 °
That envelope should not be read as a graphitic stacking
reflection. Fitting the corrected band gives an interlayer spacing
of 4.01 Å–4.08 Å, against 3.354 Å for graphite and the 3.44 Å
spacing of fully turbostratic carbon [47];
the Mering–Maire graphitization degree [48]
evaluates to
All three observations are consistent with carbonization at
140 °C yielding a humin-like polymeric solid from sugar dehydration
and condensation [5] rather than a turbostratic
carbon. Establishing a degree of carbonization would require
elemental H/C and O/C ratios, Raman
The structural result narrows the interpretation of Section 3.1. Increasing the molasses feed recovered more dry solid, particularly between 10 and 15 g, without producing a comparably large change in the FTIR or XRD fingerprint. Surface area, elemental composition, acidity, and cation-exchange capacity were not measured, so bulk similarity cannot be extended to the adsorption sites.
3.3 Residence Time Separates the Oxygen-Band Ratios
The three 10 h spectra were acquired in the same session as the 24 h set and share its band positions, so the two residence times can be compared directly. Because attenuated-total-reflection absorbance scales with contact pressure, the comparison is made on ratios to the 1610 cm band rather than on absolute heights (Fig. 3b and Table 2).
| Band ( cm) | 10 h ( |
24 h ( |
Ranges |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1700 () | 0.755 |
0.861 |
separate |
| 1025 () | 0.984 |
1.131 |
separate |
| 1510 | 0.501 |
0.561 |
separate |
| 1315 | 0.811 |
0.872 |
separate |
| 3350 () | 0.489 |
0.510 |
overlap |
Four of the five ratios have non-overlapping ranges between the two residence times, and all four move in the same direction: the 24 h products are richer in carbonyl and absorbance relative to the 1610 cm band. Saccharides carbonize hydrothermally through dehydration, condensation, and aromatization into microspheres whose hydroxyl, carbonyl, and carboxyl groups sit in a shell around a more aromatic core [46, 50], and attenuated total reflection samples that shell rather than the particle interior. The separation is the only measurable difference between synthesis conditions anywhere in this dataset. Its direction is not, however, the one a more severe treatment would give: raising temperature or residence time in hydrothermal carbonization lowers the oxygen content of the solid [51], which on the usual band assignments would lower these ratios rather than raise them.
It is a lead rather than a result. Each series contains one spectrum per feed loading and no replicate measurement, so loading variation and residence-time variation are not separated, and the width of each range is not an uncertainty on a mean. A replicated set at both residence times, with elemental analysis to anchor the band ratios to H/C and O/C, would settle whether the separation survives.
3.4 Crystalline Calcium Phases Differ Between Batches
The 25.4 ° reflection that displaces the apparent maximum of the 20 g pattern is the strongest line of anhydrite, . Seven of its eight reference lines above 10 % relative intensity are present in the 20 g pattern, and all eight in HB and HC. Two of those eight lie 0.06 ° apart and are not resolved separately, so the intensities compare over seven lines: 100:29:21:25:12:11:14 for HB and 100:22:23:20:15:10:9 for HC, against 100:29:20:20:16:15:11 for the card. Two of the unassigned patterns carry a second phase, weddellite () [52], identified from its 14.32 ° and 32.23 ° lines. Fig. 4a shows the six patterns against both reference stick patterns, and Table 3 summarizes the assignments.
| Pattern | Assigned feed | Phase | Lines matched | Anhydrite |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HA | unassigned | weddellite | 6/9 | |
| HB | unassigned | weddellite, anhydrite | 4/9, 8/8 | 42.3 |
| HC | unassigned | anhydrite | 8/8 | 13.1 |
| HD | 10 g | none detected | – | |
| HE | 15 g | none detected | – | 0.8 |
| HF | 20 g | anhydrite | 7/8 | 9.0 |
The two hydrochars assigned to MH10 and MH15 contain no
crystalline phase above a five-sigma detection
limit [53] of 222
counts
Infrared spectroscopy does not corroborate the assignment. The
sulfate
Energy-dispersive spectroscopy would test calcium and sulfur directly, and six such analyses were run, but they cannot settle this question for two independent reasons. They were run on the temperature screening rather than on the feed-loading series, so none of them is MH20; and the quantification model was fixed at carbon, oxygen, sodium, silicon, iron, and nickel, with calcium and sulfur absent from it (Section 3.5). A repeat on the three final products, with calcium and sulfur declared and the raw spectra retained, would settle it.
Calcium, sulfate, and oxalate are all constituents of cane molasses, which carries some 13.1 % ash on a dry basis, with calcium at 1.39 % and sulfate at 2.09 % of dry matter [1]. The simplest reading is therefore that feed ash components precipitate during carbonization rather than that a carbon phase crystallizes. Ash-forming elements are known to partition between the solid product and the process water during hydrothermal carbonization rather than to remain with the feed as a whole [54, 55], so the calcium carried into the solid may differ from batch to batch. The anhydrous rather than hydrated form is not a preparation artifact: the diffraction specimens were taken before the 400 °C treatment, which would itself have dehydrated any gypsum through bassanite to anhydrite [56]. These patterns therefore describe the product as formed rather than the adsorbent, which passed through that step; since the step produces anhydrite rather than removing it, the difference between batches is expected to persist into the adsorbent, though the adsorbent was not itself examined by diffraction. What the difference tracks is still open, since HA, HB, and HC are unassigned and feed loading, production batch, and washing therefore cannot be separated. What the data do establish is that the three patterns mapped to final products are not equivalent in mineral content, even though their carbon envelopes coincide. An adsorption comparison across these loadings would therefore not be comparing carbon surfaces alone.
3.5 A Separate Temperature Screening
The electron microscopy is not part of the loading series. It covers five carbonization temperatures at a single feed, was acquired in one session before the first recorded 24 h batch, and carries one spectrometer report per temperature plus one repeat. None of its samples can be matched to a final product, but it accounts for the choice of 140 °C and its compositions qualify Section 3.4.
Morphology changes across the series (Fig. 5a–e). At 140 °C the field contains discrete carbonaceous microspheres dispersed among smaller irregular aggregates, the form commonly reported for sugar-derived secondary char [5]. From 175 °C upward no discrete spheres remain: the product appears as fused sheet and block material with rough surfaces. Each temperature is represented by one field, so this is a qualitative contrast rather than a measured transition, but it is consistent with the choice of 140 °C for the loading series, the temperature that yields separable particles.
Nine diameter lines recorded on a
10000
| Sample | C (%) | O (%) | Minor (%) | O/C at. | Ca K |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 140 °C | 74.18 | 25.33 | 0.50 | 0.256 | |
| 175 °C | 74.92 | 24.74 | 0.34 | 0.248 | |
| 180 °C | 69.18 | 30.77 | 0.05 | 0.334 | |
| 200 °C | 65.33 | 33.85 | 0.81 | 0.389 | |
| 220 °C | 73.16 | 26.52 | 0.32 | 0.272 | |
| 220 °C repeat | 73.41 | 26.48 | 0.10 | 0.271 |
The spectra themselves carry a line the reports do not
(Fig. 5f and
Table 4). A peak at 3.69 keV,
calcium K
Calcium was never in the quantification model. Because the printed masses are normalized over the six declared elements, its counts are not merely unreported but redistributed among them, so the carbon and oxygen percentages for the three calcium-bearing samples are wrong rather than incomplete. The O/C column measures the size of that displacement and is not a carbonization index: it is also non-monotonic, rests on one measurement per temperature at varying working distance, and carries printed relative errors of 14 % on carbon and 19 %–22 % on oxygen. Sulfur was not detected in any spectrum.
Two consequences follow. The 140 °C product of this screening carries no detectable calcium, which is the same direction as the diffraction result for MH10 and MH15, though on a different sample. And interpreting the three final products requires an elemental analysis with calcium and sulfur declared from the start.
3.6 Analytical Range Limits the Adsorption Claims
The calibration standards form a linear relation within
1 mg L−1–5 mg L−1,
| Feedstock and HTC conditions | Yield (%) |
|
FTIR groups | Adsorbate: capacity | Regeneration | Limitation | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cane molasses (this study), 140 °C, 24 h, 10–20 g per 50 mL | 11.7–18.4a | not measured | , , , | : not validatedb | – | treated adsorbent not characterized | |
| Date-palm molasses, 180–250 °C, 2–10 h, 4 g per 25 mL |
|
|
, , , | MB: 12 | – | single capacity value | [10] |
| Date molasses, HTC then activation | – | 1584 | – | MB: 410 | – | porosity from chemical activation | [11] |
| Wood chips and cane molasses, -assisted HTC | – | – | O-groups, | tetracycline: 119.7 (unmodified 56.4) | – | iron-modified composite | [12] |
| Sucrose, 200 °C, 12 h, 15 g per 200 mL | 26.7 | 1.60 | , , , | MB: 2.07; RhB: 3.51 | 10 cycles | linearized Langmuir fit | [28] |
| Sugarcane bagasse, 250 °C, 0.5–3 h, 1:5 | – | 1.4–1.8 | , , | : 2.97–3.43 (pH 7) | – | linearized Langmuir fit | [21] |
| Sugarcane leaf, 200–240 °C | – | – | – | : 20 (synthetic), 10.25 (digestate) | – | competition by and | [22] |
| Paper sludge, 200 °C, 24 h, 0.25 M NaOH | – | 2.2 | , | : 20.09 |
|
low porosity | [23] |
| Bagasse and vinasse with , 230 °C, 13 h | – | 11.92 | atrazine: 0.273; fipronil: 0.035 | – | low affinity | [15] | |
| Bagasse and vinasse HTC, then KOH at 500–700 °C | – | 870 | fewer acidic and phenolic groups | fipronil: 249 | – | activated carbon rather than hydrochar | [16] |
a Wet-feed basis; other yields on the basis each study defines. b Measurements above the 1 mg L−1–5 mg L−1 calibration (Section 3.6).
Two explanations would restore these values without new
measurements, and neither is consistent with the measurements
themselves. Had the samples been diluted before reading and the
factor lost, the true
The exposure is narrower than a general loss of validity. Every sample absorbance lies below 1.0, where a photometer is ordinarily still linear, so detector saturation is an unlikely source of error. The assumption the extrapolation carries is chemical rather than optical. Nessler determinations have been verified against nominal concentration up to about 8 mg L−1 [59], several times below the largest value inferred here, so the extrapolation runs past the range over which the chemistry itself has been checked. Color development also depends on the reaction time, for which 10 to 30 min is recommended [59] and which was not recorded. Reagent depletion and incipient turbidity would each bias the reading low, which would inflate the apparent removal rather than scatter it. Both are documented for this chemistry: the color-forming reaction consumes reagent in proportion to the ammonia present, so an incomplete reaction underestimates the concentration, and hardness cations precipitate as hydroxides in the strongly alkaline reagent unless a complexing agent is added, producing turbidity [60]. Calcium is present in these products (Section 3.4), although whether any of it entered solution was not measured. These data cannot test either mechanism; a standard series covering the absorbance range the samples themselves occupy would settle it directly.
A validated concentration would still not assign the removal to
the carbon surface. The adsorbent had been heated to 400 °C in air,
which oxidizes part of the hydrochar carbon and concentrates its ash
in the residue [31, 61], and
the calcium phase of
Section 3.4 passes
through that step as anhydrite. Ammonium could therefore leave
solution by cation exchange against alkali and alkaline-earth
cations released from the ash, by electrostatic attraction to
deprotonated oxygen groups, or by complexation at those
groups [25, 24]. Its
apparent removal could also arise without uptake, if released
calcium made the Nessler solution turbid or if alkaline ash raised
the pH toward the / p
The shape of the time series adds a separate constraint
(Fig. 6b).
Correlations between the two replicate curves are 0.11,
Absorbance after 60 min rises with nominal initial concentration
in all three series
(Fig. 6c), and so does
nominal
The adsorption experiment therefore remains preliminary. Its safest qualitative observation is that nominal removal had occurred before the first 5 min reading and that nominal mass uptake increased with initial concentration. Reporting an optimum time, kinetic mechanism, isotherm family, or maximum capacity would assign more information to the data than they contain.
3.7 Comparison with Reported Sugar-Derived Hydrochars
Table 5 places the present products beside recent hydrothermal carbons from molasses, sugars, and sugar-industry residues. Unactivated hydrochars prepared at 180 to 250 °C were nearly non-porous: BET areas were below 1 m2 g−1 for date-palm molasses [10], 1.60 m2 g−1 for sucrose [28], 1.4 to 1.8 m2 g−1 for bagasse [21], and 2.2 m2 g−1 for paper sludge [23], within the 1.0 to 3.5 m2 g−1 reported for glucose hydrochars [65]. Areas of 870 to 1584 m2 g−1 and capacities above 240 mg g−1 appeared only after phosphoric acid or KOH activation [11, 16], which converts the hydrochar into an activated carbon. Ammonium capacities of the unmodified hydrochars lay between about 3 and 20 mg g−1 [21, 22, 23], a range narrow enough that an analytical error of the size shown in Section 3.6 would change the ranking of these materials. Regeneration was reported for two of the nine studies [28, 23]. The present products extend the comparison to 140 °C, below the temperature of any study in Table 5, with yield recorded for every batch; their surface area was not measured, and their ammonium data cannot be placed beside the capacities listed.
3.8 Experimental Requirements for a Defensible Adsorption Comparison
The loading series can be tested without changing its central
design. Each final hydrochar should first be linked to an
independently labeled synthesis batch. The ammonium calibration must
include a reagent blank, replicated standards, and standards
spanning the absorbance range the samples themselves occupy rather
than the nominal concentration range alone, with the upper limit of
the linear range established by an objective test rather than
inferred from a coefficient of
determination [57] and with the
standards made up in a matrix that matches the
samples [60]. The stock solutions should be read
against that curve rather than assumed. Samples still exceeding it
should be diluted and the factors retained, with the reagent
verified to remain in excess at the top of the range. Independent
vessels at each time point would avoid the changing-volume problem
of sequential sampling, and time points before 5 min are needed to
resolve the initial uptake. An adsorbent-free ammonium control and
an ammonium-free adsorbent blank would separate uptake from losses
in solution and from interference by species released from the
solid. Solution pH should be controlled, recorded before and after
contact, and varied across the range where converts to , and
dissolved calcium and potassium measured before and after contact
would test exchange against the ash cations. Removal percentage and
An equilibrium time should be established before collecting an isotherm, and the concentration range should extend far enough to test whether saturation is present. Surface area and pore-size distribution [66], elemental composition, and pH-dependent surface charge [67] or cation-exchange capacity are required before the comparable FTIR/XRD patterns can be related to ammonium affinity, and they have to be measured on the treated adsorbent itself rather than on the hydrochar it came from. Together these measurements would allow a direct comparison of material performance across the loading series.
4. Conclusions
Hydrothermal carbonization at 140 °C converted cane molasses
directly to a solid, and we compared product recovery, bulk structure,
and an ammonium dataset across three feed loadings. Mean wet-feed
yield rose from 11.74 % at 10 g to 17.49 % at 15 g per 50 mL water,
whereas the three products kept closely matching FTIR and XRD
fingerprints (
5. Supplementary Material
Supplementary Information: Table S1, contact-time series; Table S2, initial-concentration series; nominal values derived from the measured absorbances (PDF).